I admire visionary creators like David Lynch and Robert Aickman and Clark Ashton Smith who deliver sublime and mysterious experiences with no explanation. Their (lack of) message seems to be, “As with life, any enjoyment you get from this weird shit I’m channeling is entirely on you.”
I’ve always wanted to be that kind of visionary, and I’ve written a few dreamlike stories that offer no justification for their existence other than trying to tug on a loose thread of the universe.1
But mostly, I make gifts for people, usually ones I know. Sometimes even you.
The anticipation of someone’s reaction to my work—a laugh or a gasp or a couple of tears—is my single greatest motivation in the creative act2. Sometimes I wish it weren’t so, that I hadn’t adapted to my childhood by being “entertaining,” but I live to make people see and feel things. I like pushing buttons.3
My creative process involves a lot of cackling in anticipation for what someone specific will think of a moment or detail. When a story feels “dead on the table,” it’s usually because I’ve lost sight of who I’m writing it for, either an individual or a type of person. That’s when it’s time to refocus on what someone would actually want from this thing…either to deliver it or subvert it.
Sometimes that’s a whole story, like “The Moon’s Turned Black” that I recently sold to Nightmare Magazine. It is a modified version of the one I wrote to woo Aimee in 2006. It’s pretty rare for me to write an entire work for that purpose, but she’s worth it.
Usually, though, my presents come in the details. In A Scout is Loyal, Ted Castillo drives a Volkswagen bus because my father did, and Ginnie Castillo was raised in Flushing because my mother was. Mr. Hopkins the foul-mouthed grocery store manager is an old boss from a high school job, inserted for the amusement of a friend who is now dead. Aubrey Marsh speaks a certain way in memory of another departed friend. Protagonist Bud Castillo is half Puerto Rican in homage to my friend and former boss Pete. He’s half Jewish as a tip of the yarmulke4 to my friend Steve.
A cynical critic might call that “pandering,” though if it is, it’s the stupidest kind, pleasing a single person instead of a demographic. Some of them I don’t even know, imagining what the nerdy barista at the coffee shop who shuffles on the front of her feet might like to read.
You could ask the reasonable question of where my own creativity enters the work, and I should emphasize that my stories aren’t just strings of in-jokes. Probably the deepest act of invention, though, comes in imagining the audience I’ll never truly know.
My first “characters,” I suppose, are the people I’m writing for.
Last Saturday evening, we held the launch event for A Scout is Loyal with a great crowd of friends and family who humbled me with their willingness to huddle in the cold to hear me read from it.

A traditional venue like a bookstore might have been technically warmer, but we chose instead to host a far cozier gathering on our back patio with a fire going. We catered it the way we wanted with authentic Puerto Rican cuisine from Bud’s heritage, and we had a fabulous time chatting about the book and its era after I read a particularly gory scene inappropriate for after dinner.
It was absolutely wonderful, at least for me. My favorite thing about events like that (including Willcon, the gaming convention I’ve run from my home for 29 years) is seeing folks from different sectors of my life intermingling. My brother-in-law chats with one of my former students. A member of my D&D group cracks a joke to my sister.

At this stage in my “career,” I’ve essentially decided that success comes one reader at a time, and last weekend I had the joy of hanging out with a couple dozen of them…just like I’m hanging out with you now. Maybe we’ve met and maybe we haven’t, but I’m writing presents for you, too.
See, the funny paradox about getting really specific and really intimate is that the narrower the focus, the broader the connection. A story for everyone hits no one. A story for my mother somehow reaches your mom, too.
So thank you to everyone who came to the book launch and all of you who attended virtually in this blog and social media posts. Thank you even more for ordering the book or posting a review or telling a friend.
If while you’re reading it (or anything else by me), you get the peculiar sense that it was written for you, there’s a very good chance it was.
- If you’re curious which ones they are, “We Were Wonder Scouts” and “The Ghost Factory” are two, both available in In Search Of and Others. ↩︎
- Frankly, even in most other things I do, too: I’m always vaguely sad that no one cheers or cries after I deliver a webinar. ↩︎
- Which is why when I turn left across traffic, I always pretend to be screaming in panic for the driver of the oncoming car. As a treat. ↩︎
- Can one tip a yarmulke? ↩︎


